The spirit of new devices
Friday, January 12, 2024
Comments: 15 (latest January 23)
Tagged: steam, steam deck, valve, apple, apple vision pro, vr, spatial computing
I see that Apple's new headset (I can't say "Apple-Vision" without smirking) is available next month.
(If you click on that Apple-Vision link, you wanna wait for the Apple to boot up and then type RUN APPLEVISION
. Unmute the sound too.)
Eh, look. I am a person who loves a new toy. I'd love to play with this new thing. But I'm not going to buy one. $3500 is out of my price range for new toy vibes.
To be sure, it's not just new toy vibes. I can tell you exactly when I realized that Apple was onto something with this "spatial computing" business. It was last summer, in Pittsburgh, the day before NarraScope got going. I was trying to sort something out on the web site -- I think it was labelling which talks would be presented remotely. I'm hunched over a 13" MacBook in my hotel room, cross-checking three spreadsheets and a JSON file, plus an SSH window and a browser to preview the result.
And then, of an instant, I imagine making this Cassandra-the-Librarian whoosh gesture and flinging those six windows all around me, around the hotel room. I could just sit in the middle and see everything.
That's Apple Vision Pro in a nutshell. It's a solid idea. But I only need that whoosh once a year, at best, and $3500 just isn't the right price for it. I will be interested to see the second-gen model.
I'll also be interested to see how the headset spreads. I remember the Apple Watch and the Airpods had their definite moments of "Oh, that person on the subway has 'em, it must be real." I remember the same moment for the iPad in 2010, in fact. The devices were self-advertising.
The headset ain't. It's not a wear-in-public device. I know people have been making "Glasshole" jokes since the reveal, but in fact Apple's marketing has been extremely deliberate. They never depict someone wearing the headset in public. People wear them in their impeccably furnished homes, or maybe in the office with a couple of coworkers nearby. One shot of an airplane traveller donning a headset for privacy.
But seeing one on the street -- that idea is carefully out of bounds. I mean, I live in Camberville, so I'm going to run into someone wearing one in public. But mostly, no. Apple Vision will hide away in people's home offices. You may not even see one when zoom-chatting with someone; the headset is supposed to digitally erase itself from the face. (Though that may not work on launch -- "feature still in beta".)
Capturing spatial video in public? The headset may have a recording camera, but what Apple has announced is that you record 3D video using your phone. Same way everybody has been recording video for the past decade.
Expect a year of news stories like "Apple Vision -- is it a flop?" (There's an insatiable market for such stories, going back to the first iPhone.) I think it will be a hit, but not like other Apple hits.
Speaking of new toy love, I owe my faithful readers a followup on the Steam Deck. You recall I stumped pretty hard for the idea. I pre-ordered the Steam Deck as soon as I could, waited a year (supply chains, whee) and then it arrived in 2022.
And I used it! For a week. Since then... um, it's sat on the shelf.
I should have known, really. All my productive activity from blogging to email to code to art winds up on my desktop Mac. I could migrate some tasks to a tablet, but why would I? The Mac has better screens and I'm comfortable in this chair.
In exactly the same way, all my gaming winds up on the desktop Windows box. (Except for a few mobile games, but that list has stopped growing.) It's a good box, the monitor is big enough, and I'm comfortable in this chair. Same chair -- I just roll it to the other desk.
I have a lovely couch and a reading chair, but do I wind up playing games on them? It seems not. I have never packed the Steam Deck for a trip. So that experiment has quietly failed.
I certainly don't regret buying the Deck. $680 is well within my new-toy budget limit. I was able to test Meanwhile and Hadean Lands on the device. (Spoiler: Meanwhile worked great, HL not so much.) If I ever change my mind and decide to get hooked on a couch game, the thing is waiting for me.
I still think the Deck was a winning move for Steam, both for getting a foot into the mobile gaming market and for solidifying Proton/WINE support as a standard for developers. It is true, though, that I've never seen one on the subway.
Ah well. More IGF reviews tomorrow, I promise.
Comments from Mastodon
@zarfeblong I'm in the opposite camp. I wanted, and got, a Steam Deck for Christmas, and I've already used it way more than the second-hand gaming computer that I picked up two years ago. I'm just not that hardcore a gamer, and there's enormous appeal in a device that I can just pick up, press the On button, and be playing within literally a second.
@zarfeblong Hmm - I am entirely a couch gamer, for physical reasons -- I don't want to be using the same machine/chair/etc that i use for work due to back and arm issues. But with my switch that I travel with, I have more and more vision issues, so it's a big TV or else it seems.
@zarfeblong semi-relatedly if you know anyone in Pittsburgh who wants one of the *nineteen* Kinects my advisor is getting rid of as part of a lab organizing spree, they have until Wednesday to retrieve one...
@lea @zarfeblong Wow. I have 5 or 6 Kinect v1ās I should probably be offloading as well. Used them for a music video a decade ago. Am holding back on offering to pay postage and handling for a few of your labās if theyāre the later Kinect type because I really shouldnāt be collecting hardware.
@lea @zarfeblong Thereās something so neat about hardware that captures RGB and depth video, plus the later kinects had an API thatād return skeletal position data, so nifty. Iām curious what a lab did with 19?
@lea @zarfeblong Whoa, clicked to read the original blog post and my Mastodon posts (hi) were below the post as comments ā first time Iāve seen the Wordpress fediverse integration in action!
Regarding people using the Apple Vision Pro outside their beautiful living rooms, if its optics are anything like those of the Oculus Quest 3 and Pro that would be inadvisable. The Quest screens can be easily burned by sunlight. So donāt remove it outside or leave it on a windowsill!
@zachnfine @lea Hi! Itās not Wordpress; itās a very small custom script.
https://blog.zarfhome.com/comments
https://github.com/erkyrath/bloggor/blob/master/site/js/fedicomments.js
I have no idea what the headset optics are like. I suppose Iāll read some reviews next month, you know, out of sheer curiosity.
@zarfeblong @lea Iām very curious if theyāre using the intensely weird āsuper pancakeā optics from Limbak, a company Apple purchased a few years ago. Would make the headset even more unique than it already is. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1j2WViE8kFo
Oh, geez, I just realized that I have no idea what Fireproof Games has been up to since The Room VR. If they port *that* to Apple Vision, I might have to buy the damn thing on the spot.
(I have no idea if Appleās interaction model matches The Room, but I bet the Fireproof folks have investigated the question.)
Even further realization:
If Disney releases a āTronā workspace for the Vision Pro, I will scream like a twelve-year-old. (Which is how old I was when the original Tron was released.)
@zarfeblong Thinking about that.
Good news! You can interface with a computer just like in TRON.
Bad news! Your trackpad sucks for aiming a frisbee in a 3D space.
@elithebearded @zarfeblong Apple just needs to license the Kinect at that point. Rebrand it the iRoom or something.
The Deck has been real nice for me but it's basically been a replacement for my PS4. If I had a Windows game machine already I probably wouldn't have bothered, if I'm leaving the house it's usually to get AWAY from the option of sinking all day into games.
And yeah the "woosh" factor is neat for the Vision but it's probably a lot more cost-effective to just use an iPad as a second screen or something. Maybe once the Vision 5 has brought the cost down.
@zarfeblong My economic perspective is different, of course (spending $8 on a book I need for work is a painful decision sometimes), but my thought about the Steam Deck on the subway is that anyone who has one, no matter what its price means to their relative buying power, doesn't want someone to just take it ... And that's what I'd picture happening to any Steam Deck exposed on most subway systems I've been on. š®
(On the other hand, I've seen people openly use tablets on public transport) š¤·